202212051136 Solution to 1978-AL-AMATH-II-3

A smooth homogeneous hollow right circular cylinder with open, flat ends stands freely on smooth horizontal ground so that its axis is vertical. Two spheres A and B of radii a and b (a<b) and weights W_a and W_b respectively rest in equilibrium inside the cylinder as shown in the diagram. Suppose that the internal and external radii of the cylinder are c and d respectively, where c<(a+b).

i. Show that the vertical forces acting on the spheres reduce to a couple. Determine the moment of the couple.
ii. Determine the minimum weight of the cylinder such that it will not overturn.
iii. A third sphere C, identical to A, is then placed on top of B in contact with the cylinder. Determine the minimum weight of the cylinder so that it will not overturn for the two possible equilibrium positions of C.

You may assume that the cylinder is tall enough to hold all the spheres.


Roughwork.

WLOG reduce the problem from three-dimensional to two. Begin with three free-body diagrams as follow:

So many unknowns I don’t know how to get set.

(to be continued)